My thoughts with spoilers ahead
I don’t know why, but I feel compelled to write a review on
the newest Spider-Man film,
The Amazing Spider-Man
. Possibly because I haven’t written a film review in a long
while, or maybe it is the writer in me, one who has read enough, watched
enough, or hell even created, enough stories with Peter Parker in them, that I
feel I deserve to criticize the film.
I know I DON'T actually deserve to criticize the film, relax, but it's a
character that is intertwined with my child, teenage, and adult life. One I am still close to; even now I’ve
got Spider-Man books within my reach.
Like I said – I don’t’ know why I feel compelled to write a review. I just do.
Going into the film I had reasonable expectations: cool
action sequences, another look at Peter Parker’s origin, and solid
Marc
Webb
music selections. I got all of
these, and a bit more, but other then those three items I was fully open to
whatever Webb planned to do with Peter Parker.
The casting was one thing I was unsure of going into the
movie.
Martin
Sheen
and
Dennis
Leary
cast as Uncle Ben and Captain Stacey were my main concerns. Sheen as Uncle Ben felt so wrong – it felt like they were using his screen persona as Martin Sheen to make us care about Uncle Ben. The
film did not build up his character enough, and although I felt emotionally
attached to the scene of his death it was all due to Peters reaction and my
previous knowledge of Uncle Ben. I did quite like that they didn't use the "with great power" line word for word Leary was better than Sheen but had the same constraints, relying more
on him being Dennis Leary than Captain Stacy. More on Captain Stacey later though, they did do some things
right with him that I would like to touch upon. I was sold on
Emma
Stone
as Gwen with her performance, and
Andrew
Garfield
had a bit to prove in my eyes – and I am unsure if he did.
Garfield played a great Peter Parker – his Spider-Man was a
little lacking in my opinion. Garfield's Peter was different from
Tobey Maguire's
, his Peter was confident as well as awkward, which he did a spectacular job of juggling both characteristics. His Spider-Man though was not as
confident, the way he stood tall as Spider-Man felt off - I don’t know if I can
explain it other then just the way he carried himself. His sarcasm was there albeit toned down
and with the exception of one scene he did very little talking with the mask on. The writers’ choice to have Spider-Man
less talkative bothered me but the switch was good for the Peter character and
Garfield played awkward better than Maguire ever could.
By the time the third act was beginning to shape up was
when Webb started to lose me. Right
after the construction workers help Spider-Man, it all began to
fall apart, as if the webs became too tangled. Webb hit the nail
on the head perfectly though with the city of New York getting behind Spider-Man. Overall the story felt too common of
a tale – the clock is ticking and Spider-Man will have to save the day. I probably sound harsher then I am
meaning but the finale felt run of the mill, but before the story came to a
close something I didn’t expect happened. Where I felt Sheen wasn't right for the role, I saw that Leary was right for it, but he was not given screen time to
really shine.. My hopes were
dashed, and I honestly thought, just before the third act, that Sony Pictures was going
to base the new Spider-Man series around the Captain Stacy/Gwen Stacy
masterpiece by
Stan
Lee
and
John
Romita
. Of course they were going to take liberties but the rushed
climax of that arc really disappointed me. The few scenes Leary and Garfield had together were
glimmering hopes of a sequel based around their odd relationship - ending with
would have been the "gut punch" of this film. That clearly isn't happening now.
Maybe I'm hinging too much of my expectations on what I hoped
for in the future with the Sony Pictures reboot. Walking out it wasn't complete enough for me. The acting, for the most part, and
chemistry was great, the action was well thought out, and the use of the modern
world (the Spidey cell phone) played perfectly into the film. Yet the typical countdown plot line was
lacking and the rushed ending abruptly cut this film down from great to good.
It may sound like I am picking apart the writing of the film completely. And, well, I kind of am BUT they did do many things right. The scene where Spider-Man removes his mask and hands it to the kid before saving him may go down as one of my favourite scenes in all of film. It was pitch perfect.
In my mind this Spider-Man trilogy could have been great
with this film playing out the way it did – with the exception of Captain Stacy
surviving. The second film would
deal with a new villain, while still setting up Norman Osborn, and the death of
Captain Stacy hitting much harder.
Ending the trilogy on a sad note with the Green Goblin and Gwen’s death would be superb, but
we all know Hollywood would never go for that. Right?