Skylight Diner and Five Guys Burger and Fries
New York City has to have good burgers right?
Well I spent four days in New York and I can vouch for that. Every burger I ate was fantastic. It also seemed like every third meal was a burger (or street meat, but that’s for another post). Not that I am complaining about eating burgers all the time!
The first time
George
and I attempted to grab a burger was a waste of time. We walked to
Burgers & Cupcakes
, which we both heard were fantastic, but the line up out the door for burgers was quite large. After standing around for 15 minutes we decided the wait wasn’t worth it when we could walk down the street and find more delicious food.
So George and I walked down the street and found
Skylight Diner
. A couple blocks away from our hotel room, and open 24 hours. We both knew the chance of us returning at 4 AM was a good one, although it never happened, but we would return the next day since it was also close to the convention center.
|
|
Skylight Chili Burger
|
Skylight Diner is a decent sized establishment that has a huge selection of items on the menu. I made a comment about waffles, but in reality waffles just meant I could get breakfast items anytime, and I love when I can get omelets for lunch or dinner. They also had a good selection of seafood, sandwiches, and pasta on top of all the traditional breakfast items, and of course, burgers.
I settled on the Skylight Chili Burger, with fries, cornbread, a pickle and a little coleslaw. George ventured into the sandwich arena and ordered some pastrami. Although my burger was good, it was nothing special. The black bean chili used really clashed with the taste of the crisp lettuce and fresh tomato. I could imagine eating a bowl of that chili and finding it delicious but it just did not work well on the burger. Describing the fries is easy as they were horrendously undercooked and had no flavor.
As our food showed up
Ryan
joined us and ordered himself a Bleu Cheese Burger. Just as I finished my plate his arrived and just looking at his burger I realized I clearly made a mistake in what I ordered.
|
|
Bleu Cheeseburger
|
So when we returned to the Skylight Diner for lunch the next day, both George and I, a Bleu Cheese Burger was ordered. It was beyond what I expected since it was a simple burger with just lettuce, tomato, and lots of blue cheese. Normally blue cheese needs to be paired with something strong to offset the strong flavor of the bleu cheese itself but this burger did not have that. I expected the overpowering flavor of the bleu cheese to be salty and really distract the flavor from the burger. That did not happen though and I was left with a spectacular burger. As a bonus, the fries were much improved from the next day. Still nothing to rave about but they were cooked more so they at least had a texture to them and were not mush this time around.
As much as I wanted to eat more street meat (lamb over rice) on my last day in New York, George,
Rich
and
Jon
took me to
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
. They had nothing but amazing things to say about this place. So my expectations were really high going in.
Let me tell you that this burger, while expensive, and artery clogging (just an assumption), is probably the best burger I have ever eaten.
This burger has two patties, bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, ketchup, relish and mustard, plus I could have added grilled mushrooms, grilled onions, green peppers, jalapenos and my choice of A1 Steak Sauce, Bar-B-Q Sauce or Hot Sauce for free. The Cajun fries were excellent as well. Normally Cajun fries are good but too salty, I never thought these were too salty, just full of a lot of flavor.
This may have been the best $15 I spent in New York. The only knock on this place is their menu consisted of burgers, hot dogs, fries, and a grilled cheese for vegetarians.
So does New York City have the best burgers?
Maybe. I cannot argue against that since I only tried a small scale of burgers but I definitely could see an argument for it. I will have to return one day to find out for sure!!
|
|
Bacon Cheeseburger
|
What I ate: Skylight Chili Burger with fries, slaw, bread, and pickle - $9.50 (before taxes)
Dollar Value: 3/5
Burger Taste: 2/5
Fries Taste: 0/5
Menu Selection: 5/5
Overall: 2.25/5
What I ate: Bleu Cheese Burger with fries, slaw, bread, and pickle - $8.50 (before taxes)
Dollar Value: 3/5
Burger Taste: 4/5
Fries Taste: 2/5
Menu Selection: 5/5
Overall: 3.5/5
Yes I know the two above are the same place but different days added a different perspective.
What I ate: Bacon Cheeseburger with Cajun fries - $15.16
Dollar Value: 2/5
Burger Taste: 5/5
Fries Taste: 5/5
Menu Selection: 2/5
Overall: 3.5/5
Skylight Diner
402 West 34
th
Street
New York, NY 10001
212-244-0395
Five Guys Burgers and Fries
316 West 34
th
Street
New York, NY 10036
212-564-6115